/ Game Dev With AI / Indie Game Publishers: What They Take and Give
Game Dev With AI • • 13 min read

Indie Game Publishers: What They Take and Give

What indie game publishers give and take, with one publisher's published averages, a 30-contract analysis, a worked recoupment table and six terms to refuse.

Indie Game Publishers: What They Take and Give

Indie game publishers give you money before launch and people you don't have, and they take a share of every copy for years, usually after taking most or all of the early revenue until their advance is paid back. The only publisher I found that publishes its own numbers, Whitethorn Games, says it takes 29.45% of net revenue on average, has asked for as little as 8% and as much as 40%, and puts an average of $280,000 of direct funding into a title. A 2020 analysis of 30 indie contracts found an average advance of $318,000 and a 60/40 split that favours the publisher until recoupment and flips after. Whether you want a deal depends on which of those things you can't supply yourself, and the arithmetic below is built to answer that for one price and one advance.

Every list that ranks for this phrase names publishers. None of them shows what a deal contains. So this article does the other half, from the pages that say anything, loaded today.

Sixteen Publisher Pages, One With Numbers

The lists point you at submission pages, so I tried sixteen. Seven loaded. This is what each one says about money.

Publisher page Loaded today What it says about terms
Whitethorn Games yes averages, ranges, funding, marketing spend, a contract template
indie.io yes "we earn when your game earns ... no recoup against your cut"; no percentage
No More Robots yes nothing; wants "a pitch document, a build and a good idea of where you'd like to go"
Coffee Stain Publishing yes nothing; a pitch form; lists Valheim and Deep Rock Galactic
Kwalee yes nothing; "from marketing and production to funding and platform partnerships"
Playstack yes nothing; "from financing, QA, localisation and store management"
Humble Games yes nothing on the pages I found
Hooded Horse, Curve, Akupara 403 unknown
Devolver 429 unknown
Raw Fury, Team17, Fellow Traveller, tinyBuild, Thunderful 404 on the submission URLs unknown

Fourteen of sixteen either say nothing about the deal or would not load. That silence is itself information. The publisher knows what a standard contract looks like and you don't, which is the exact imbalance the lawyer in the 2020 analysis set out to correct, and it is why the one page with numbers is worth more than the lists combined.

What a Publisher Gives

The Odin Law explainer from March 2025 lists the value plainly. Publishers provide "funding for development, marketing the game, and obtaining necessary permits and ratings board approvals to enable distribution of the game," and the same page names "marketing, localization, porting, and distribution" as the costs that get deducted before you see royalties, which tells you what they spend on.

The pages that loaded say the same in their own words. Kwalee offers "funding and platform partnerships" and "an in-house team of 60+ QA experts." Playstack lists "financing, QA, localisation and store management." indie.io leads with "60+ distribution channels" and "all 3 major consoles." Whitethorn puts a figure on the marketing piece, "$56,000" average direct marketing spend per title.

The give, as I read those pages, is four things. Cash before launch. Marketing you'd otherwise buy or skip. Console ports and platform relationships. And a team that has launched before, which is the part no spreadsheet captures and the part No More Robots means when it says it works "with a small number of games at a time."

What a Publisher Takes

Here are the averages from Kellen Voyer's GDC Summer 2020 talk as PC Gamer reported them, from 30 contracts his firm negotiated or was sent, beside Whitethorn's own page. They are six years and one publisher apart, so read them as two data points, not a market.

Term Voyer's 30 contracts (2020) Whitethorn's page (loaded today)
Advance or funding "$318,000" average, paid on milestones; some deals have none "$280,000" average, "$350,000" highest
Share during recoupment "60 percent of the game revenue goes to the publisher, and 40 percent to the game developer" not stated as a split; "no so-called recoup multiplier"
Share after recoupment "60 percent goes to the developer, and 40 percent to the publisher" 29.45% to Whitethorn on average, 8% to 40% range
Full publisher take until recouped "42 percent of the contracts" not stated
Developer's overall take "at least 53 percent" with a big advance, "55 percent with smaller advances" not stated
Term length "around 6.5 years"; "38 percent last forever" not stated
IP developer keeps it in "93 percent" template published; not summarised here
Pricing "Publishers always set pricing" not stated

Two numbers in that table decide more than the headline split, in my reading. The first is the 42 percent. In nearly half the 2020 contracts the developer saw nothing from sales until the advance was paid back in full. The second is Whitethorn's 16.6% standard deviation across its own offers, which says that even one publisher's deals are not one deal. The share you get is negotiated per game, and the range is wide enough that "what percentage do publishers take" has no single honest answer.

The Recoupment Arithmetic, Worked

Recoupment is the mechanism the lists never explain. Odin Law's definition is that "once the game starts generating revenue, the publisher retains a larger share of that revenue to recover its initial investment, which may be all of the initial revenue." Here is what that does to your cash at one price.

Assumptions, all mine. The game sells at $19.99. The store keeps 30%, which is the widely reported Steam figure and the same assumption the money article on this site uses, so $13.99 per copy reaches the deal. The advance is $150,000, below the 2020 average because I'd expect a solo dev's first deal to be. No refunds, no regional pricing, no marketing deductions, which flatters every column equally.

Four deal shapes. A is the harsh one, the publisher keeps every dollar until the advance is back, then you get 60%. B is Voyer's average, you get 40% during recoupment and 60% after. C is the shape indie.io describes, a share from the first copy with no recoupment, which I've set at 50% because the page states no number. Self is you, alone, keeping all of it and paying for your own marketing.

Copies sold Net to the deal A, you get B, you get C, you get Self
5,000 $69,965 $0 $27,986 $34,982 $69,965
20,000 $279,860 $77,916 $117,916 $139,930 $279,860
50,000 $699,650 $329,790 $369,790 $349,825 $699,650
100,000 $1,399,300 $749,580 $789,580 $699,650 $1,399,300

Under A the first developer dollar from sales arrives at copy 10,720. Under B it arrives at copy one, but the advance is not repaid until copy 17,866 because only the publisher's 60% counts against it.

Now add the thing the table hides. In A and B you also received $150,000 before launch, and you spent it making the game. At 5,000 copies, the self-publisher has $69,965 and a finished game they funded from savings. The developer under deal A has $0 from sales and a game that was paid for. That is the trade in one row. A publisher is insurance against the 5,000-copy outcome, paid for with the 50,000-copy outcome, where the self-publisher keeps twice what deal B pays.

C looks best at 20,000 and worst at 100,000, which is what a flat share with no advance does. It is a marketing partner, not a funder, and the pages that offer it describe themselves that way.

I'd run this table with your own price and your own honest sales guess before you send a single pitch. The budget article here is where the burn rate that sets the advance you'd need comes from.

Six Terms Voyer Says to Refuse

The same 2020 talk listed contract terms an indie should reject. I'm quoting them because they are the closest thing to a public checklist I could find, and because every one of them can only be fixed before you sign.

  1. "A 50/50 revenue split after recoupment. Go for higher." His averages put the developer at 60% after the advance is back.
  2. "Giving the publisher the option to publish a sequel under the same terms." A right to negotiate is normal. A right to the same deal is not.
  3. "Publisher ownership of IP." Developers kept it in 93 percent of the contracts he read.
  4. "A perpetual publishing agreement term." Thirty-eight percent of his sample had one, and his example of why it hurts is the HD remaster you want to make ten years later.
  5. "A publishing agreement with no audit rights," meaning no way to have an accountant check the publisher's books.
  6. "A publishing agreement in which the developer has no say over how soon the game can be discounted or bundled," which protects you from a publisher in trouble slashing your price for cash.

Odin Law adds the one I'd watch hardest, the one that hides in definitions. Royalties are usually paid on net revenue, and "more aggressive publishers may try to include things like internal costs or overhead as deductions." Whitethorn's page answers that directly by saying its "time, expertise, years of experience, etc. are not 'expenses' to the developers and are not recouped." If a contract's definition of net does not say that, ask why.

What to Send

Whitethorn's publishing page lists what it wants "in order of importance," and it is the only pitch list I found that ranks. Demo first, "a playable build that represents your game." Then video or gifs. Then screenshots and concept art. Then "a breakdown of your monthly burn rate" with milestones. Then the elevator pitch, the engine and version and source control, and the team.

No More Robots wants "a pitch document, a build and a good idea of where you'd like to go." Kwalee routes you through a portal form. Coffee Stain has a form. The pattern across all of them is that the build outranks the deck.

That reorders the work, and I think it is the most useful thing on any of these pages. The demo and store page you'd build to earn wishlists without a publisher are the same artefacts a publisher asks for first, so building them is not a detour from the pitch. It is the pitch. The one-page design document on this site is the overview line item, and the burn rate is the budget article again.

Odin Law notes a shift worth knowing before you send anything. "Some publishers recently (as of this writing, 2025) are electing to invest in a game later in its development process, after the game has been largely self-funded," and in those cases "take a lower percentage in royalties since the publisher is taking on less overall risk." A pitch with a demo and a wishlist count is a late-stage pitch, and late-stage pitches get better splits. Whitethorn's 8% floor is what that looks like at the edge.

Do You Need One

Decide by what you lack, not by whether a publisher would say yes.

What you lack Route What it costs you
Money to finish the game a funding publisher, deal A or B the early revenue and a share for the term
Marketing you can't do or afford a late-stage publisher or a first-dollar partner, deal C a lower share, no advance
Console ports and platform contacts a publisher with console pages, or a distribution partner a share, or fees
Time and confidence only self-publish with paid tools indie.io's tool tiers start at "$19.99 /month" and the wishlist plan is free

My own view, and it is a view, is that a solo dev's first small game rarely needs a publisher and rarely gets one, because the advance on offer is sized for a team's burn rate and the split is sized for a game that sells tens of thousands. A publisher becomes worth the share when the game is bigger than your savings or your reach. Until then the table above says the same thing in numbers.

The Questions People Ask With This One

Do indie games have publishers. Some do, and the pages above are who. Most small games on Steam ship without one, and Steam Direct is that route.

Who are the biggest indie game publishers. The impress.games database sorts live Steam followers and reviews per publisher, which is a better answer than any list's opinion. Coffee Stain's page lists Valheim and Deep Rock Galactic, which tells you the scale at the top.

Who are the top three game publishers. That question is about the companies behind AAA releases, not indie deals, and this page won't help with it.

Which indie publishers are accepting submissions. Every publisher page that loaded today has a form or an address, Whitethorn, No More Robots, Coffee Stain, Kwalee, Playstack and indie.io. Whitethorn takes pitches "at any stage of development." The impress database has a filter for it.

Which indie publisher is considered the best. I'd say the one whose terms you can read before you sign, and today that is a list of one.

What percentage do publishers take. In the 2020 sample, 40% after recoupment and 60% during, with the developer ending up at 53 to 55 percent overall. At Whitethorn, 29.45% on average with a range from 8% to 40%. Epic's 2020 publishing terms, as reported, were at least 50% to the developer after full funding was recouped. Any single number you read elsewhere is one of those, rounded.

Before You Pitch

Open Whitethorn's template and read it once, even if you never pitch them, because the page says its documents are "real instruments used to sign real games," anonymised. Run the recoupment table with your price. Write the burn rate. Then build the demo, because it is the first line on every list that says what it wants, and it is also the thing that lets you skip the whole question.